skip to Main Content
  • News
Gearinger Law Group Teams Up With Schwaiger Law Firm To Sue Sonoma County Over Deputy Murder-Suicide

Brian Gearinger has teamed up again with civil rights attorney Izaak Schwaiger of the Schwaiger Law Firm. Together, they represent the estate of Mari Bonnici and her three young children in a federal civil rights lawsuit against Sonoma County, the City of Santa Rosa, and two Sheriff’s Office supervisors.

Bonnici worked as a detention specialist for the Sonoma County Sheriff’s Office. In August 2025, her former partner, Sheriff’s Deputy Jeremy Lyle, shot and killed her. Lyle took his own life hours later after a standoff with SWAT. The couple’s three children, all under two at the time, now live with their paternal aunt and uncle. The lawsuit, filed September 8 in federal court in San Francisco, alleges civil rights violations, wrongful death, and negligent supervision.

The complaint tells a troubling story. In November 2024, Lyle allegedly struck Bonnici, bloodied her face, and locked her out of their home. He stayed inside with the children, making suicidal statements. Lyle’s brother called the Sheriff’s Office. He warned that Lyle was a danger to himself and others and should not be on duty. A sergeant went to Lyle’s home and concluded that Lyle qualified for an involuntary psychiatric hold. According to the complaint, a captain ordered the sergeant not to place one. The sergeant then told Lyle that Bonnici’s report had prompted the visit, and left him armed and on duty.

The warning signs kept coming. Lyle allegedly threatened another woman at gunpoint and attacked a Sheriff’s Office coworker. Through it all, he kept his badge and his guns. A week before Lyle killed her, Bonnici called 911 to report new threats. The complaint alleges that a Santa Rosa police dispatcher learned Lyle was a deputy, told Bonnici the couple “needed to grow up,” and sent no officers.

“Mari was killed because of bad leadership at the Sheriff’s Office,” Izaak Schwaiger said. Deserei Parga, the children’s aunt and legal guardian, calls the department’s repeated inaction a catastrophic failure.

Brian and Izaak have worked together before to hold law enforcement accountable when it fails the people it serves. Here, the lawsuit alleges that the Sheriff’s Office protected one of its own instead of the woman he threatened. Three children will now grow up without their mother.


Additional coverage of the case is available from:

Back To Top